Jay Kaplan's 10-year journey fighting for LGBT rights
The quest for equality requires more than courtroom battles
Originally printed 6/2/2011 (Issue 1922 - Between The Lines News)
The American Civil Liberties Union has long been an advocate for LGBT equality. Michigan's ACLU chapter has a special tool in its belt for fighting for LGBT rights: the LGBT Project.
Since 2001, the project has defended gay men from police entrapment and unfair imprisonment, fought for same-sex couples' rights to benefits, lobbied for LGBT protections at the state capitol and plenty more.
The project is driven almost entirely by Jay Kaplan. He's won a few important battles, but there's still a war against LGBTs in our state - a war which Kaplan has learned a variety of ways to fight.
Taking the sting out of sting operations
Police raids, gay targeting and unfair imprisonment aren't just the black-and-white snapshots of LGBT history in the last century. Those problems are alive in this century, too.
In a 2001 Rouge River sting operation, undercover Detroit police officers posed as gay men, hoping to arrest and charge people for violating an "annoying person's ordinance." Roughly 1,000 men were arrested. Many had their vehicles impounded and were slapped with a $1,000 fine.
When Kaplan joined the project in 2001, this became his first case.
In attempt to appear gay, young cops in short shorts smiled and waved at park visitors, Kaplan explains. "They were trying to get people to do things that could be considered annoying so they could arrest them," Kaplan says.
"(The ordinance) would prohibit things that are protected speech under the constitution. It's not illegal to wave at somebody; it's not illegal to smile. Can you imagine people getting arrested for things like that? It's ridiculous."
Kaplan sued on the behalf of seven plaintiffs in federal court, challenging the constitutionality of the ordinance. It wasn't easy to find arrestees who were willing to come forward, but the Triangle Foundation (now Equality Michigan) helped find people.
What was the outcome of the suit? For starters, the seven plaintiffs settled out of court for a large cash sum. And the annoying person's ordinance "is off the books," Kaplan says.
More than a legal war
Sometimes legal battles aren't best fought in courtroom arguments. They also need to be fought with education.
Kaplan took this softer approach when he worked with the Michigan Department of Corrections to stop marking gay inmates as "active homosexuals" on all of their records. Inmates who entered the system after 2006 no longer have such a marker.
How did Kaplan do it?
"Letters. Talking. Explaining that there's no reason for this, and the significance here," Kaplan says. He worked with administrators in the department, helping them understand that labeling an inmate as homosexual only exacerbates the homophobia that often exists in correctional facilities.
"We're limited on what we can litigate in our state," Kaplan says. "We have an incredibly conservative appellate court system in Michigan, which in the past has issued a number of decisions very damaging to the cause of LGBT civil rights and hostile towards civil rights in general. You don't want to file something that's just going to create worse law. So a lot of times what you do need to do is education. Hopefully some persuasion."
So sometimes you have to get people on your side, not just fight them on issues?
"Exactly," Kaplan says. "Sometimes you just can't win with our courts. Especially for the last decade. It was very, very difficult. Just a dead end. You had some very ideologically-driven justices on the court who had some very strong opinions on some of these issues."
Win some, lose some
Kaplan encountered some of those very strong opinions a few years ago.
In 2008, Kaplan was fighting a battle that began in 2004, when Michigan citizens approved Proposal 2, which added an amendment to the state constitution that prohibits same-sex marriage and civil unions.
"Once it became part of the constitution, some started saying cities couldn't offer domestic partner health insurance benefits," Kaplan says. "And then the attorney general, Mike Cox, issued an opinion saying he thought Kalamazoo offering domestic partner health benefits was unconstitutional." The ACLU filed a lawsuit, requesting a declaratory judgment and arguing that the benefit is merely an employee benefit - not a benefit that's only legally deserved by married couples.
Despite an early success at the trial court level, the case made its way up to the Michigan Supreme Court, which ruled against the ACLU. It said that the amendment means no public institution can offer any form of same-sex relationship recognition, including offering health benefits.
Since then, Kaplan has helped public institutions, such as universities, change their eligibility requirements to offer a "plus-one" option in their benefits packages. This means that an employee can allow another person of his or her choosing to share a health plan.
What you don't know...
Kaplan also spends a lot of time fighting for rights that many LGBTs don't even know they don't have.
For all that he's fought for, Kaplan's pet project is Michigan's restrictions against same-sex couples adopting children.
Kaplan has a warm, friendly, even teacherly voice. But when he starts talking about adoption, his tone begins to stretch in outrage.
"We have one of the broadest restrictions in the country," he says - broad restrictions that aren't even officially on the books.
The culprit? Proposal 2, again, which bans same-sex marriage. Judges who grant adoptions have also interpreted it to mean that same-sex couples can't adopt children together.
This means only one parent signs the adoption papers, and "your children don't have the legal protection of two parents," Kaplan says. It also means "children might not be able to access the health insurance of (the non-legally recognized) parent."
This unofficial, but widely practiced restriction on same-sex parent adoption also makes for messy custody battles if the couple breaks up, Kaplan says. The "unofficial" parent loses all rights to see the children he or she raised.
Overall, Kaplan says, "it undermines the stability of families."
Making a map
"When you look at the polling that has been done, most Michiganders favor civil rights protections for LGBT people, they believe there should be forms of relationship recognition," Kaplan says. "But when we look at our policies, when we look at our practices, we're out of sync."
Not only are LGBTs not allowed marriage or adoption in Michigan, but they're also not protected from discrimination in housing or employment - even though nearly every other minority class imaginable is.
This means that Kaplan and his team have plenty of work to do.
"I think we owe a duty, and by we I mean LGBT organizations and programs, to set forth a road map: How are we going to get there, what's it going to take, what needs to happen. I think people have to have a clear understanding of what it all involves. It's not just a magic wand, filing a lawsuit or passing a law. It's kind of a holistic approach."
To learn more about the Michigan ACLU LGBT Project, go to http://www.aclumich.org.
More Pride Guide
- Michigan Pride 2016 Floats On Without Parade
- Motor City Pride Returns to Downtown Detroit this Weekend
- Singer Seeks to Deliver a 'Message of Encouragement' During Motor City Pride
- Detroit Soul Singer Declares That Now is Her Moment
- Newcomer in 'No Rush' to Sell Her Soul
- Sick of Sarah Ready to Rock Out Ferndale Pride
- In Focus: Michael C. Lary and Ferndale's 2015 Municipal Equality Rating
- Ferndale Pride Volunteer Receives Good Neighbor Award
- MotorBall Ready to Rev its Engine Again
- Hotter Than July 2016
- Michigan LGBT Health Summit: Meeting the Primary Care Needs of the LGBT Population
- BTL Columnist's Art to be Displayed in Detroit's Scarab Club
- Summer Pride Calendar
- Art Radiates at Affirmations
- Ferndale Ready to Celebrate its 'Biggest Pride Ever'
- Motor City Pride Entertainment Lineup Announced
- Sick of Sarah to Headline Ferndale Pride
- Covenant House Benefit to Feature Broadway Stars
- LGBT Staffers Presented with Presidential Award
- Motor City Pride Vendor Gallery
- Embassy Suites by Hilton DetroitTroy/ Auburn Hills
- AIDS/HIV Organizations
- Matrix Ryan White HIV/AIDS Program
- Unified - HIV Health and Beyond
- Wellness AIDS Services
- Animal Shelter
- Humane Society of Huron Valley
- The Guild of Artists & Artisans
- Bassett & Associates, PLLC
- Bidwell Tovarez PLLC
- Buckstad & Associates
- Iglesia Martell Law Firm PLLC
- Armene Kaye, Esq.
- Shelton & Deon Law Group
- Auto Collision
- Great Lakes Collision
- Art Moran Buick GMC
- Fairlane Ford
- Jorgensen Ford
- SUBARU-Hodges Imported Cars, Inc
- Williams Auto World
- Comerica Bank
- Campus; Student and Alumni Groups
- University of Michigan - Dearborn, LGBTQ Inclusion Initiatives
- Carpet Cleaning
- Hagopian Cleaning Services
- Grand Traverse Resort & Casinos
- MGM Grand Detroit
- Thomas's Catering
- AG Chocolates
- Community Centers
- Prism of Possibilities Psychotherapy
- David Harris Ph. D.
- Denise Joseph, Ph.D.
- Rosemary A. Jozwiak and Associates
- Joe Kort, Ph.D. & Associates, PC
- Counseling Education
- Michigan School of Professional Psychology
- Credit Union
- Michigan State University Federal Credit Union (MSUFCU)
- Demi C. Kazanis DDS Family & Cosmetic Dentistry
- Ron T. Williamson DDS
- Tyrrell Electric
- Event Planners
- C & N Party Rentals
- Exchange Student Placement
- International Experience
- Farmers Market
- Royal Oak Farmer's Market
- Financial Services
- Michigan State University Federal Credit Union (MSUFCU)
- Gift Shops
- Five 15
- Heating & Cooling
- C&C Heating & Air Conditioning
- Allstate Insurance
- State Farm Insurance
- Abracadabra Jewelry / Gem Gallery
- Fredrick Jewelers
- Miner's Den Jewelers
- Landscape Supplies
- Rock Shoppe
- Plymouth Nursery
- Leather Gear
- Noir Leather
- Legal Organizations
- American Civil Liberties Union of Michigan
- Moving Companies
- Men on the Move
- Flint Institute Of Arts
- Opera Company
- Arbor Opera Theater
- Pet Boarding
- 4 Paws Community Center
- Pet Day Care
- 4 Paws Community Center
- Pet Supplies
- Premier Pet Supply
- Manzo Eye Care
- Physicians/Gynecology & Obstetrics
- Partridge Creek Obstetrics and Gynecology
- Political Organizations
- Equality Michigan
- Pools & Spas
- B & B Pools and Spas
- The Print Stop
- Professional Organizations
- GM PLUS - General Motors LGBT & Ally Employee Resource Group
- Real Estate/Agent
- RE/MAX Showcase Homes
- The LindaLom Team at Trillium Real Estate
- Real Estate One
- Religious & Spiritual
- Dignity Detroit
- Edgewood United Church, United Church of Christ
- Metropolitan Community Church of Detroit
- Whosoever Ministry
- D'Amato's Neighborhood Restaurant
- Fishbones Rythym Kitchen Cafe
- The Laundry
- Symphony Orchestra
- Ann Arbor Symphony Orchestra
- Detroit Symphony Orchestra
- Michigan Theater
- Williamston Theatre
- Patterson Dog & Cat Hospital
- Uptown Adult Superstore
- Wine Shop
- Cloverleaf Fine Wine
- Women's Health
- Planned Parenthood Mid and South Michigan
- Namaste Yoga
- KT Tunstall on Why Kissing Girls Wasn't Just a Phase and Channeling Her Masculinity ('I Feel Like I Have a C*ck')
- My 11 Minutes with Dolly Parton: How She's Helped Her Gay Mountain Family & Her Plan If She Were President
- Idina Menzel on Working Toward LGBT Icon Status, a Lesbian Elsa & Angry Gays Who Oppose Her 'Beaches' Remake
- Creep of the Week: Laura Ingraham
- Equality Michigan Hires New Transgender Victims' Advocate
Sign up to receive our weekly newsletters today!
This Week's Issue
Download or view this week's print issue today!