Sides Square Off On Fla. Gay Marriage Ban
By CURT ANDERSON
Originally printed 7/10/2014 (Issue 2228 - Between The Lines News)
MIAMI (AP) - Attorneys for gay couples, the state of Florida and proponents of so-called traditional marriage squared off Wednesday in a lawsuit seeking to overturn a ban on same-sex marriage enshrined in the state constitution by voters in 2008.
Like similar cases filed across the country, the Florida gay couples' lawsuit contends that the ban is discriminatory and violates the U.S. Constitution's guarantee of equal protection under the law. Attorney Jeffrey Cohen, representing the six same-sex couples who filed the lawsuit, asked Miami-Dade Circuit Judge Sarah Zabel at a hearing to issue a ruling like those in 21 other cases nationwide declaring the ban unconstitutional.
Cohen noted that Florida allows gay people to adopt children but bars them from taking the final legal step to become a legitimate family in the eyes of the law.
"It's the right of a person to choose who they love and who they make their future with," Cohen said. "We should not make anyone a second-class citizen."
Attorney General Pam Bondi, whose office intervened in the case just last week, takes the position that U.S. Supreme Court rulings - including the one last year that struck down the federal Defense of Marriage Act - give states sole power to define marriage. Florida defined it as between one man and one woman in the 2008 voter referendum.
"It remains binding precedent," said Deputy Solicitor General Adam Tanenbaum.
Zabel did not immediately rule and gave no indication when she would. She took notice, however, of the numerous state and federal rulings striking down gay marriage bans in other states - including one in Kentucky on Tuesday - since the Supreme Court's ruling on the federal marriage act.
"What about the flood of cases that has been coming down?" Zabel asked a lawyer for groups supporting the current ban.
The hearing drew a packed crowd into a main courtroom and a spillover room, many of them proponents of gay marriage sporting pictures of adopted children and snapping photos of what many viewed as a historic occasion. There were also those favoring the ban, some wearing American-flag stickers that read "Respect My Vote," while others prayed and quietly sang hymns. There were also groups of chanting protesters outside the courthouse.
"Peace and love!" shouted opponents of the ban. "Enough is enough!" countered those favoring it.
Attorney Matt Staver of the Liberty Council, representing several groups supporting the traditional marriage definition, urged Zabel not to rule hastily to allow time for more evidence to be gathered. Staver also questioned the legal reasoning of the numerous state and federal judges who have recently voided other gay marriage bans and said society is better off with opposite-sex marriage.
"The optimal environment is the opposite-sex mom and dad. Gender does matter," Staver said. "Without opposite-sex marriage, there is no procreation."
There are currently 19 states and the District of Columbia that allow same-sex marriage. Lawsuits challenging bans in all other states are pending, some of them on appeal, and many legal experts say ultimately the U.S. Supreme Court is likely to resolve the issue at some point.
A separate lawsuit filed in federal court in Tallahassee seeks an order forcing Florida to recognize legal same-sex marriages performed in other states. That case is also pending.
- Will U.S. Supreme Court Resolve Marriage Debate?
- Mississippi Judge Overturns Same-Sex Marriage Ban
- Study Suggests Genetic Link For Male Homosexuality
- Shelter in Kansas City Won't House Gay Couples
- Gay Marriage Issue Now Linked To Ohio Senator
- Another Top Ohio Republican Speaks On Gay Marriage
- Pope Reinforces Traditional Family Values
- Election 2014: LGBT Candidates Make Some History Across U.S.
- Republican Sweep Captures Senate And Some Pro-Gay Governors
- LGBT Veterans Still Denied Equal Federal Benefits
- GLSEN Releases New National School Climate Survey On America's Middle And High Schools
- NCAVP 2013 Intimate Partner Violence Report
- Transgender Michigan Teen Shares Story On National Stage
- CEO Of Apple Tim Cook: 'I'm Proud To Be Gay'
- Guide To Elections Across the U.S.
- 5th Circuit Court Sets Date To Hear SSM Cases
- Federal Gov. To Recognize Same-Sex Married Couples In Six More States
- Hook-Up Related Homicide In Pennsylvania
- Bishops Scrap Welcome To Gays In Sign Of Split
- Federal Judge Strikes Down Arizona Same-Sex Marriage Ban
- Roseville Goodyear
- Cancer Support Groups
- Gilda's Club Grand Rapids
- National Organizations
- Pet Boarding
- Club Pet Too
- Political Organizations
- LAHR-PAC (Lansing Association for Human Rights Political Action Committee)
- Deb's Diner
- Lez Hike
- Substance Abuse
- Together We Can
- Wine Shop
- Barefoot Wine & Bubbly
- Namaste Yoga
Enter contests to win great prizes like CDs, DVDs, concert tickets and more
- Q&A: Andy Cohen On His (Almost) Tell-All Book, 'Nasty' Names Gays Call Him
- Divine Intervention: Bette Midler Talks Early Gay Support, 'Diva' Degradation & Twerking ('Girls, Please!')
- Q&A: Melissa Etheridge On Letting Go, Moving On & The Song 'I Didn't Wanna Do'
- Pastors Challenge Civil Rights For Michigan Gays
- Republican State House Candidate Has History Of Scandal
Sign up to receive our weekly newsletters today!
Stigma: a mark of disgrace associated with a particular circumstance, quality or person. Hearing the words "I'm HIV-positive" made Bryan (names and some details have been changed) freeze.View More World AIDS Day
This Week's Issue
Download or view this week's print issue today!
Sign up to receive our weekly newsletters today!